Groups | Blog | Home
all groups > flash (macromedia) > september 2004 >

flash (macromedia) : Why Not Scenes???????


Tom Unger
9/6/2004 7:30:46 PM
Leo D.;
I suspect many (perhaps most) developers abandoned them in favor of
working with multiple timelines long ago, but the use of scenes is OK, so
long a one is aware of how they work (how frames are targeted from other
timelines etc). Scenes are really just an editing "convenience". -Tom Unger

Tom Unger
9/6/2004 7:36:38 PM
Bjarne;
Flash scenes do not divide a file into parts that can be independently
downloaded--on the contrary all scenes are parts of the main timeline in the
exported swf. Perhaps you are using scenes to produce separate swfs?
-Tom Unger

captainnimster NO[at]SPAM tokyopop.com
9/6/2004 11:20:51 PM
Scenes are a leftover from the early flash days and are still kept in
the program to keep some backward compatibility.

Its been awhile, but I remember reading an article on how flash
compiles movies, so when you go and create your swf file, timelines
get compiled into one timeline, thus all scenes get compressed to a
single timeline I believe, and not kept seperate.

Furthermore, scenes is not seen as an object in Actionscript, so that
is a problem right there.

Your best bet is to use frame "labels".

[quoted text, click to view]
Leo D.
9/6/2004 11:24:24 PM
Everyone says using scenes is BAD, but no one says why.

Why are scenes bad for some simple navigation?

Bjarne Vincents
9/6/2004 11:29:39 PM
Who says it bad, I use it a lot (always) to divide huge scenes into smaller
more editable items,
and I think it works just fine. It is also better for web, you can divide the
size of the file
the user have to download into smaller perts.
regards
Bjarne
Annie123
9/7/2004 12:24:05 AM
Leo D.
9/7/2004 1:38:53 AM
All great comments. Thank You.

Most of the time I use loadMovie, especially for web deployment.

Just seem to like the ease of the scenes workflow over seperate docs.

sonek-du NO[at]SPAM 163.com
9/7/2004 6:33:05 AM
?????????????
Jeckyl
9/7/2004 10:02:51 AM
If you read the posts the talk about scene being bad, they usually say why

It is all to do with using them in script.

Partly because flash is buggy wrt scenes .. it can product bad code

And partly because you can only use scene names as literals (can use a
variable or expression for scene)

And partly because you can only use scene names in actions directly called
from scene level (not in clips).

And partly because you can then get confused between frame numbers within a
scene, and frame numbers within the whole movie (which is what you get at
from script)

If you use them ONLY for splitting your movie into logical segments, scenes
are fine. Just do not try to use them at all in script.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button