Groups | Blog | Home
all groups > flash (macromedia) > october 2005 >

flash (macromedia) : tired of hype email about new product!!!


Chris (mudbubble)
10/17/2005 6:58:17 PM
Download the free trial (full version) and take 30 days to explore it forst hand. Macromedia is very
proud of this release and the overall development community is excited about it also. I would rather
see the fluff from a proud and dedicated company as opposed to a company who doesn't care so much
about their product to bother showing it off - just my opnion - there was just as much fluff with
previous versions - well, almost anyway :)

believe me there IS a reason for all this excitement - I have already uninstalled MX 2004 since
Flash 8 because I no longer have any need to open it again. Again - my opnion. See for yourself -
it's very easy to find info on flash 8 on MM's site:

http://www.macromedia.com/software/flash/flashpro/productinfo/buy/
http://www.macromedia.com/software/flash/flashpro/productinfo/features/
http://www.macromedia.com/software/flash/basic/
http://www.macromedia.com/software/flash/flashpro/productinfo/reviews_news/
http://www.macromedia.com/software/flash/flashpro/productinfo/faq/

these pages contain very little fluff and in most cases, none.

good luck - hope this helps.

--> www.mudbubble.com - www.keyframer.com - Team Macromedia <--
--> http://www.macromedia.com/devnet/flash/3d_animation.html <--
--> http://groups.google.com/advanced_group_search?hl=en&as_ugroup=*flash* <--
--> mudbubble mailing list: stserv@mudbubble.com with "subscribe news@mudbubble.com" in body <--

[quoted text, click to view]
Chris (mudbubble)
10/17/2005 7:19:03 PM
wow - a 30-day free trial isn't conducive enough for you? really? do you want them to come to you
and click on the "download" button for you?
All that info on the products page taking too much of your time to read? Should they install the
software relative to flash into your brain after you take the blue pill?

:)

Nor do I have the time to dig for what they have done. They should
[quoted text, click to view]
Chris (mudbubble)
10/17/2005 7:20:48 PM
oh, i really need a new car - but i dont have the time to read about the one i want or go to the
dealership - they should judt know what i want and drive it over to my house for me :)

i'm really just having fun with you - not a flame here - your position on all this is very amusing
Chris (mudbubble)
10/17/2005 7:23:54 PM
Fair enough - nobody is forcing you to upgrade - especially if it isn't of any use to you. There are
many cool new things about flash and what you can do with it - designers and developers alike -
many examples popping up all over the web - more and more in time.


[quoted text, click to view]
David Stiller
10/17/2005 8:34:57 PM
TerrySimkin,

[quoted text, click to view]

I encourage you to keep Googling. :) ActionScript 2.0 is still the
highest version of ActionScript publicly available (AS3 will be possible
with the new Flash 8.5 Player and future IDEs, including Flash's cousin,
Flex Builder 2). The difference in Flash 8 is that AS2 features additional
packages that tap into new functionality of Flash Player 8. In fact, the
new features are especially relevant to game design, since they boost visual
performance significantly, allow for new (arguably better) hit testing, and
offer new levels of realism to special effects.

I've seen samples of Flash 8 tile-based games (Mario Bros clones) that
are incredibly fast because of the new bitmap caching. Blend modes allow
more realistic shadows and anaglyph 3D (red/green glasses) that have
otherwise only been available to Director movies (Shockwave plugin).

As Chris said, no one's forcing you to upgrade, but heck, I'm glad I
did!


David
stiller (at) quip (dot) net
"Luck is the residue of good design."

David Stiller
10/17/2005 8:46:03 PM
Terry,

[quoted text, click to view]

I haven't purchased the Rhodes book yet, but it's on my list. I have
had the chance to communicate with Rhodes a couple times, and he's a good
guy. I also like Ed. 2 of the Makar book, though if you have 5 games books,
you may already have read it.

[quoted text, click to view]

You'll be pleased, I'm sure. His Essential ActionScript 2.0 is good for
anyone, but perhaps especially nice for someone like you who has experience
in more traditional languages. His ActionScript the Definitive Giuide is
only as recent as Flash MX (not even MX 2004), but by and large, the
Player-mechanics and ActionScript background he covers are still entirely
relevant (the relevance may only diminish slightly with the new virtual
machine in Flash Player 8.5, though the new Player will continue to support
the current VM [i.e., AS1 and AS2]).

[quoted text, click to view]

It's great to see Flash being put to so many uses!


Now, to 2m ... wow, what an ego boost! It means a lot to me to that you
like my contributions here. I love these forums and, like you, get a lot
out of the Flash community. Thanks for the props! :)


David
stiller (at) quip (dot) net
"Luck is the residue of good design."

David Stiller
10/17/2005 8:48:27 PM
[quoted text, click to view]

I should add: much as I would enjoy the muscles and olive skin, I am
absolutely nothing like a god, Greek or otherwise. ;)


David
stiller (at) quip (dot) net
"Luck is the residue of good design."

TerrySimkin
10/17/2005 10:39:21 PM
I teach introduction to game development with Flash MX 2004. Like the product
and the students do well with it. But all the hype about the new product 8
does nothing for me. I need to find out if anything is done to Flash to help
game development or to modify Actionscript!!! Anyone know or know of wher I
can find out. I get lost in all of Macromedia's fluffy web site!!!! I have
written to Macromedia before but no responce.
2m
10/17/2005 10:54:51 PM
I'd think that there are a lot of improvements that can really help with game
design, but I dont know what kind of games you're talking about, but fore one
thing the new BitmapData Class can really help with rendering performance (even
with collision detection as Grand Skinner proofed - thanks David for pointing
that out).

But why donn't you just go, download the trial and have a look yourself.

And consider SE|PY even the Gods use it!
TerrySimkin
10/17/2005 11:12:14 PM
This is an introduction to game development class so the projects are
relatively simple.
I will look into BitmapData Class.
You wrote, "And consider SE|PY even the Gods use it!" Lost me! what is SE|PY
and what gods, hahaha

Thanks for the answer. But still have not found a big reason to upgrade to
Flash 8. Nor do I have the time to dig for what they have done. They should
be supplying that on a silver platter.

TerrySimkin
10/17/2005 11:20:36 PM
Hi thanks for taking the time to answer.

I visited all the sites you listed. If I was starting out again I would have
the school purchase the current version of Flash.

However, the advanced add ons to Flash 8 are of little use to my course at the
level the students need.

Nothing was in the list to make Actionscript improved in any substansive way.
I do like Actionscript 2.0.

I assume in time the books for my course with Flash MX 2004 will disappear and
I will be forced to select a current book and move to Flash 8.
2m
10/17/2005 11:50:02 PM
Hy Terry,

I can't shake off the feeling that you are angry at someone, and I can't
really understand how a teacher like you would be so defensiv about the
program/subject/technology you're teaching.

May be I'm wrong about all this, and it is way past midnight here, so I won't
dwell on that, but even if you don't like Macromedia as a Company, you might
consider the Flash Community worth a lot more.

I'm using this as an intruduction to my answer to your question:

SE|PY is a great AS editor (http://www.sepy.it/) it's made by Alessandro
Crugnola from Italy, whom I consider one of my heros for doing so.

And the "Gods" your asking about are some of those whom i admire for their
ability with Flash (supernatural!) and especially for their ability to teach.
For example Colin Moock (you should have his books) or David Stiller and some
others you might meet here.

(I'm using the term God in a kind of greek mythological, not meaning to offend
anyones faith).


TerrySimkin
10/18/2005 12:22:22 AM
Hi 2m,

Sorry if I sounded angry. I have been on a steep learning curve developing
the intro to game development course as the start of a degree program,
Animation and Graphics Game Programming at the New Hampshire Technical
Institute. I selected Macromedia Flash as a quick way to introduce game
concepts to early programmers and new game development.

I do have to admit the flood of hype from Macromedia about the new software is
annoying. Someone said in a reply that I was looking for a ?blue pill?. Well
that would be nice; a clear capsulated review or the reasons to upgrade. I do
not want to download the new Flash and start digging. I have my hands full
with this new course and the other full load teaching assignments I have?

I have very impressed with the speed the students have picked up the
Actionscript and made Flash do lots of very interesting simple games. We are
using Rhodes book and it is great.

Macromedia Flash MX 2004 Game Development
Glen Rhodes
1-58450-309-2
CHARLES RIVER MEDIA, INC.

Macromedia Flash was a very big pleasant surprise. I have been writing games
in C++, Java and C# with a number of APIs including DirectX for a number of
years. The learning curve is very steep with these tools!!! Nothing here I
wanted as an introduction to game development for new students.

I have a book shelf of Macromedia Flash books, five on game development alone.
I have recently sent away for a Colin Moock book. Need something to cover the
language better than Macromedia web info and books. Hope this is it!

The math and physics teachers here are learning Flash to help with a course
coming up on Beginning Game Math and Physics.

I will be waiting and reviewing over the next few months about the new Flash
verson.

Terry


Chris (mudbubble)
10/18/2005 9:39:18 AM
:) peter - that is *exactly* why i reacted to this post the way I did. :p



[quoted text, click to view]
Peter Blumenthal
10/18/2005 10:30:56 AM
[quoted text, click to view]

Surely as a teacher of Flash, it's vital that you *make* the time?
--
-------------------------------
Remove '_spamkiller_' to mail
-------------------------------



2m
10/18/2005 7:32:10 PM
OK Guys,

I'm mostly in your boat on this one, but somhow I feel compelled to point
somthing out:

It can be frustrating to try to deal with Macromedia for simple pawns like me
an him. An expeirience those in the higher echelons of the community very
likley won't have (with the the good connections into the company that most of
you have)
Don't get me wrong, you are great, and you deserve that! It's good for all of
us.

<episode>
When I was angry, that as a European I should not only pay about $150 more for
my studio8 upgrade (no taxes counted, english version download), but that I
also was punished with 2 of days of extra waiting for preordering the product,
I wrote an email asking/compaining about it. After 2 das I got the answer that
my downloads would be ready. Replying that I know that by now, and that is not
answering my question I was plainly ignored. And I thought 150 extra bucks
would buy worth a second email ;-)
</episode>

OK - way past and gone for me, but ther are other perceptions of Macromedia
than yours.

But I really would like to ask Terry if his experiences with other companies
are really better.
(Mine are even worse with Adobe (sic!), Corel - Microsoft I won't even mention
- and I don't need help often!)
AddThis Social Bookmark Button