all groups > macromedia flash sitedesign > april 2004 >
You're in the

macromedia flash sitedesign

group:

Site Critique



Site Critique ladyluna
4/5/2004 4:09:12 PM
macromedia flash sitedesign: Hi all,
Would you please critique my site, it is only partially flash, but I would still appreciate your comments.
Thanks,
Re: Site Critique plecoguy
4/5/2004 5:12:13 PM
Where is it?

Re: Site Critique ladyluna
4/5/2004 5:27:56 PM
Yeah, that would help:
[L=MySite]http://63.225.252.5/rwco/index.html[/L]

Re: Site Critique Ed Massey
4/6/2004 12:18:36 PM
Hi Ladyluna,

Reviewed on PC IE5+ and NN7, 512Kbps, Fplayer7

Flash video is fine - distingtive and crisp, but for the length of pre-load
I think you ought to make more of it once you are inside the main site.

1. The header section.
It feels a little cramped up top: a little white space above the very
top maybe? Although this cramped feeling maybe due to point 3 (see below).

2. The 'Our Approach' section....
Why are you using a scroll box? - This is a little irritating as you have
to horizontal and vertical scroll in both NN & IE.
It seems that you are writing this to appear in an envelope-sized window -
if so fine - just format the scrolling content so the user does not need to
horizontal scroll, else get rid of the scoll box.

3. General alignment...
The right-hand edges of you banner image, top nav and text content dont
align - i reckon it'd look better-contained if they did.
The left-hand edges of the main body of text-content, the contact line and
the ©-notice don't align either.... just looks a little untidy.

4. link colours - not so sure about the tone of the green text links - maybe
try to match it to the tone of the section title (that appears under the
horizontal graphic).
And less sure about the red roll-over colour.

Apart from my minor gripes I think your imagery is well presented and tight.
Good luck!

Ed



Re: Site Critique +()[\\/];
4/6/2004 1:44:13 PM
first of all you should go and optimize all the images... there are huge :(


[quoted text, click to view]

Re: Site Critique ladyluna
4/6/2004 5:32:11 PM
Thank you both for your comments and suggestions. Much appreciated!
AddThis Social Bookmark Button