Groups | Blog | Home
all groups > iis smtp nntp > march 2005 >

iis smtp nntp : Reading news over HTTP?


Eric Dan
3/21/2005 11:49:03 PM
Hi,

Is there any support in the news server (IIS 6) for reading news over HTTP?

If the above support does not exist and I know that many organizations use
this scenario (news over HTTP) is there a complementary product? any other
ideas?

--
Thanks
Jason Brown [MSFT]
3/25/2005 12:00:00 AM
There's no built-in support, no. There are numerous third-party products for
this though - you might want to take a look over at www.asp.net - they may
well have a community project open on this subject.


--
Jason Brown
Microsoft GTSC, IIS

This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights.

[quoted text, click to view]

Jason Brown [MSFT]
3/26/2005 12:00:00 AM
Well, it's not my department to comment on licencing and pricing but I will
note that Exchange Server as a standalone product is very much aimed at the
enterprise; medium to large businesses.

Small Business Server bundles Exchange at a very affordable rate, but you
are limited on the number of clients which can connect.


--
Jason Brown
Microsoft GTSC, IIS

This posting is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights.


[quoted text, click to view]

Peter D. Hipson
3/26/2005 10:04:05 AM
Another alternative is Exchange Server which does support HTTP
newsgroups. IMHO, the licensing issues are so convoluted and
non-understandable that it is unclear whether you can allow anomous
public access or not. I did ask Microsoft for a definative answer and
even they could (would?) not come up with one. Once MS gets its
license issues more sane and logical, Exchange Server is a viable too.
Right now, I'd say there are better, less complex (legally and
technically) solutions.

It would be nice if Exchange server didn't bother with client
licensing... IMHO (again) MS is missing the boat here: Exchange Server
client licenses are so expensive that it virtually eliminates the
product from serious consideration for many potential users. But then
again, it is MS's product, so they can do as they like. I just wish I
could give my consulting clients better news about costs using a MS
solution!



On Sat, 26 Mar 2005 14:47:25 +1100, "Jason Brown [MSFT]"
[quoted text, click to view]

PeterD, the Darkstar Network
To email, fix my address!
Peter D. Hipson
3/27/2005 9:39:08 AM
Jason, that describes Exchange quite well. However, for a solution for
many, Exchange's licensing model is not 'friendly'. I've had to
install other products with customers because of this, and that
translates to lost sales for MS. However, neither you, nor I, will be
able to change this...

For example, say I'm an ISP and offereing email to my customers. I can
charge, if I'm lucky maybe 14.95/month for the service. That's $180 a
year per client. Now, if I restrict each client to one email address
(that is unrealistic, however) and a client license costs me about $80
per client (street price, not list!) that means that of my gross
income, I spend almost 50% just for the client email license! That
leaves me with $100 to cover cost of services, hardware, and whatever
else there is. At those costs, it is not effective--I'm better off
with other solutions (which may not have all the functionality, but
"bang for buck" do blow Exchange out of the water...

---real case study:

I really think the most amazing thing is that MS was not able to
clarify how, if at all, when NNTP server parts of Exchange are
available to the public at large, what cleint licensing is needed, if
any! I asked, they could (or would?) not tell me. Where does that
leave me? Either I forget about client licensing and hope that MS
doesn't decide to sue me, or I find a solution that is more cost
effective.

Care to guess what solution was implemented?

--- end of case study!

This issues also affect many small businesses...

I'm not ragging on you, Jason, just trying to get my point across.

On Sun, 27 Mar 2005 14:37:13 +1000, "Jason Brown [MSFT]"
[quoted text, click to view]

PeterD, the Darkstar Network
To email, fix my address!
Eric Dan
3/29/2005 2:55:04 AM
Thanks a lot for all your responses Jason and Peter.
Eric

[quoted text, click to view]
AddThis Social Bookmark Button